How to get a strong critique from Alex
Five minutes. Works for journal articles, thesis chapters and reports.
Upload the whole paper, ask for a critical appraisal or evaluation, and tell Alex what lens to use. Those three things make the biggest difference.
1. Upload the full paper
Alex reads up to about 50,000 characters, which covers most journal articles. Pasting only an abstract gives a thin critique, because Alex cannot check the methods, tables or conclusions against each other.
2. Say what kind of critique you want
Words such as critically appraise, evaluate, identify weaknesses or assess the methodology tell Alex to reason more deeply before it answers. A plain request to summarise gives you a summary.
3. Name your lens
- "Appraise this as a peer reviewer for a high-ranked journal."
- "Assess whether the statistical methods suit the data."
- "How well do the conclusions follow from the results?"
- "Is this study design strong enough to support a policy recommendation?"
4. Ask for a structure
For example: "Give me strengths, weaknesses, threats to validity and three questions I would put to the authors." A structure keeps the answer easy to scan and easy to copy into your notes.
5. Follow up
The first answer is a starting point. Ask Alex to expand on one weakness, check a specific claim against a table, suggest what additional data would strengthen the study, or compare the paper with another one you have uploaded.
6. Check before you cite
Alex is a thinking partner, not a reference. Verify its points against the paper before you rely on them in your own work, and keep your own judgement in charge.
A prompt to start with
Critically appraise this paper as a peer reviewer. Cover the research question, methodology, sample, analysis, and whether the conclusions are supported by the evidence. End with the three most serious weaknesses and one question I should ask the authors.